If I observe my thoughts, I notice that they often serve to fill in something that isn’t immediately present or fully within my awareness. In other words, my mind is constantly engaged in processes of prediction and explanation—anticipating what might happen next and making sense of what I observe.
For example, when I see the sky is grey, I might think, “It’s probably going to rain today.” In that moment, my mind predicts a future event (rain) based on an observation (the grey sky). At the same time, it offers an explanation: I’ve seen grey skies lead to rain before.
These mental operations aren’t just intellectual exercises—they’re practical tools for navigating uncertainty. Yet, while they often serve us well, they are not infallible. Predictions fail, and explanations can be flawed. This is where logic, and specifically informal logic, plays a crucial role. Informal logic helps us make these processes explicit, enabling us to evaluate and refine the way we fill in the gaps in our awareness.
Informal Logic: Reasoning for Everyday Life
In The Sources of Knowledge, I outlined an epistemology that describes the types or sources of knowledge: sensory perception, reasoning, and intuition. Each plays a vital role in how we understand the world. Sensory perception gives us data, reasoning allows us to analyze it, and intuition provides quick, often pre-conscious, pattern recognition.
Logic functions as the bridge between these sources. While formal logic focuses on abstract structures like syllogisms or proofs, informal logic deals with the messy, context-sensitive reasoning of everyday life. It’s about analyzing and improving how we form beliefs, make decisions, and understand the world around us.
Informal logic enables us to test intuitions against evidence: Are our gut feelings supported by observation? It helps us to refine predictions into reliable inferences: Can we move from a vague sense of what might be true to a well-supported conclusion? And further it can help us evaluate explanations in context: Do they fit the complexity of the situation? By formalizing these mental operations, informal logic helps us navigate uncertainty with greater clarity and confidence.
The Relationship Between Beliefs and Emotions
Beliefs are not only intellectual—they are deeply tied to our emotions. When our beliefs align with reality, our emotions can be proportional to the situations we face. Conversely, inaccurate beliefs can lead to irrational fears, anxieties, or even depressive thoughts.
For example, if I believe that every grey sky guarantees a storm, I might feel unnecessary anxiety every time clouds appear. Alternately, if I underestimate a real threat, I might fail to prepare adequately, leaving myself vulnerable.
A rational mind, grounded in logic, protects us from these extremes by helping us refine our beliefs. This mental balance promotes emotional stability and well-being. By ensuring that our beliefs are accurate and evidence-based, we avoid irrational fears and anxieties, challenging exaggerated or unfounded thoughts, reducing emotional distress. Accurate beliefs give us confidence to face challenges with a clear and steady mind, fostering resilience and mental clarity.
This connection between beliefs and emotions ties directly to Aristotle’s view of virtue, as I discussed in Harmonizing Ethics. A virtuous life is not just about right action but about cultivating the emotional and mental stability that allows us to respond appropriately to life’s challenges. Logic, in this sense, is a tool for achieving that balance.
Features of Ideal Reasoning
To refine our intuitions and raise them to the level of inference, logical reasoning should have the following features:
- Considering multiple explanations: Open-mindedness to alternatives avoids premature conclusions.
- Reality testing explanations: Observing outcomes ensures that our reasoning aligns with evidence.
- Mindful, nonjudgmental observation: Seeing what is actually there, rather than what we want to see, reduces cognitive distortions.
- Openness to revising beliefs: Flexibility allows us to update our understanding as new information emerges.
- Choosing the best-fit explanation: Logic helps us select conclusions that most closely align with the evidence.
These principles align with informal logic’s emphasis on improving reasoning in real-world contexts. They also reflect its ethical dimension: by reasoning well, we not only make better decisions but also live in greater harmony with ourselves and others.
Case Study: Is the World Broken?
To illustrate how logic can help refine our beliefs, let’s examine a common implicit belief: “The world is broken.” This belief is emotionally charged and can lead to feelings of despair, helplessness, or cynicism. But is it accurate? Let’s subject it to rational scrutiny.
There are undeniable challenges in the world: inequality, climate change, political instability, and more. Personal experiences of struggle or systemic failure may reinforce the belief that the world is fundamentally flawed. Media coverage often highlights disasters and conflicts, creating a sense that everything is going wrong.
Despite these challenges, there are significant areas of progress: reductions in extreme poverty, advancements in medicine, and technological innovations. Many individuals and communities are thriving, creating art, solving problems, and building meaningful lives. Historical perspective shows that the world has always been a mix of challenges and triumphs—it is not uniquely “broken” now.
After careful thought, we might conclude that the world is more accurately described as complex and unfolding. It has both good parts and areas that need improvement. Instead of being “broken,” it might be seen as engaging: a dynamic space full of challenges, but also abundant opportunities to make a meaningful difference.
This revised belief doesn’t deny the reality of problems but reframes them in a way that fosters agency and hope. By applying informal logic, we’ve refined a belief that could lead to despair into one that promotes engagement and possibility.
Challenging the Myth of Cold Rationality
It’s worth addressing a common misconception: that being logical means being cold, detached, or even pessimistic. This doesn’t have to be the case. Logic, as explored here, is a profoundly life-affirming practice. It isn’t about suppressing emotions or ignoring the richness of human experience. Instead, it’s about aligning our thoughts and emotions with reality in a way that empowers us to live with clarity, balance, and purpose.
Far from being cold, logic allows us to engage more deeply with the world. It refines our beliefs so that our emotions are not dictated by fear or misunderstanding but are instead proportional, grounded, and constructive. It transforms despair into curiosity, uncertainty into exploration, and disconnection into awe.
Logic as a Path to Flourishing
Ultimately, logic is not just about intellectual clarity—it’s about human flourishing. By bridging intuition, belief, and reasoning, informal logic helps us engage with the world more effectively, refining our understanding and promoting emotional stability.
In this way, logic is a tool for navigating the flow of reality. It allows us to align our beliefs with evidence, refine our predictions, and ensure our emotions are grounded in an accurate understanding of the world. This process is central to personal growth, ethical living, and the pursuit of well-being.
Further Reading
To deepen your understanding of informal logic and its connection to critical thinking and emotional well-being, consider the following resources:
- Critical Thinking Skills by Stella Cottrell. This accessible guide explores the core principles of critical thinking, including how to evaluate evidence, identify assumptions, and construct well-reasoned arguments. Cottrell’s work provides practical tools for improving everyday reasoning and making better decisions.
- Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy by David D. Burns. A cornerstone of cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), this book explains how to identify and challenge distorted thinking patterns that contribute to anxiety, depression, and other emotional challenges. It complements the discussion of logic in this post by demonstrating how accurate beliefs support emotional stability.
Photo by Vardan Papikyan on Unsplash
Feeling Momentum 
Leave a comment